BioWatch UK: Participatory biodiversity assessment in the UK: building environmental governance.
Differences between non-scientific and scientific conceptions of biodiversity have implications for ways in which biodiversity is measured, valued and assessed. Local people, if given the opportunity to discuss survey findings and observations, often provide interpretations and insights that otherwise may have been missed were the results interpreted solely on a scientific basis. Involving communities, amateur enthusiasts or 'the public' in assessment of biodiversity can change values and interest levels of those involved. This can help to raise awareness of the Convention on Biological Diversity, and increase public interest in meeting its targets. Furthermore, the role of environmental governance, as an entry point for broader societal participation in governance is beginning to be recognised. We aim to explore this potential in collaboration with the Department of Politics and International Relations.
In the ETFRN Conference, although participation was weighted towards developing countries, there were many registrations from UK government and non-governmental organisations. Discussions during the follow-up seminar on Policy Implications of PAMEBs, held at the offices of the Department for International Development, indicated high levels of interest, and a wealth of relevant work in the UK which has not yet been documented. We therefore have an important opportunity to compare and analyse UK experience with that in developing countries. There are useful lessons in both directions: UK achievements in developing Local Biodiversity Action Plans are recognised as exceptional in contributing to the implementation of the Convention on Biological Diversity, and the UK benefits from a high level of amateur interest in natural history. On the other hand experiences in Nepal, Indonesia, Philippines and Colombia, among others, may indicate ways in which to strengthen community decision-making about resource management.
Project Downloads
Our workshop for BioWatch UK in 2003 was a resounding success. 55 representatives from academic institutions, conservation organisations and local councils contributed to a lively day, and feedback so far has been extremely positive.
The workshop provided great opportunities for meeting people working in the biological recording field, and stimulated much discussion as to the worth of our research, and future directions for our work. Many participants offered us the opportunity to organise focused group discussions with groups of volunteers, to provide a way of validating our results so far, and comparing opinions of those working as 'staff' and 'volunteers'.
Workshop Report
- Full Report [PDF: 439KB]
- Coverpage[PDF: 644KB]
- Contents [PDF: 62KB]
- Overview [PDF: 78KB]
- Programme [PDF: 73KB]
- Introduction by Anna Lawrence [PDF: 71KB]
- Presentations [PDF: 178KB]
- Biowatch team presentations [PDF: 85KB]
- Summary of the group discussion sessions [PDF: 97KB]
- Feedback from the Workshop [PDF: 54KB]
- Annex 1: Participant's list [PDF: 40KB]
- Annex 2: Examples of Codes of Conduct [PDF: 105KB]
- Annex 3: Comparison of biodiversity monitoring in the UK and The Netherlands [PDF: 63KB]
- Annex 4: Speaker mini-biographies [PDF: 67KB]
Individual Worksop Presentations
- Debbie Jackson: BBOWT's Reserve Surveying Programme [PDF: 63KB]
- Sarah Whild: A top-down or bottom-up model for biological recording in Britain - which is the most sustainable? [PDF: 63KB]
- Peter Challis: Engaging the Community: the Sussex Hedgerow inventory project. [PDF: 62KB]
- Penny Webb: The involvement of young biological survey volunteers with the National Trust at Hardcastle Craggs, West Yorkshire. [PDF: 87KB]
- Emma Pilgrim: Plantlife International's Common Plants Survey: the progress so far. [PDF: 78KB]
- Trevor James: Sharing Information about Wildlife: the development of the National Biodiversity Network.[PDF: 67KB]
Individual Summaries of the Biowatch Team Talks
- Stuart MacPherson: Farmers welcome the grey partridge: LBAP implementation in East Lothian. [PDF: 64KB]
- Sarah Gillett: What do you think? Findings from the BioWatch Survey. [PDF: 78KB]
- Muna Baig: The Voice of the Silent Force: A case study of volunteer involvement in biodiversity monitoring in Oxfordshire. [PDF: 51KB]
- Abigael Baldoumas: A Role for Volunteers in Biodiversity Interest Intermediation. [PDF: 76KB]
